The best old ice cube tray offers a nostalgic and reliable way to craft perfect ice, ideal for cocktail enthusiasts and those who appreciate vintage kitchenware. Unlike modern silicone or plastic designs, these classic trays, often made of metal or durable BPA-free plastics, provide a different ice-making experience and aesthetic. Choosing the wrong one can lead to stuck ice, difficult release, or even water leaks, diminishing the joy of preparing your favorite beverages and wasting your money.
With a variety of materials and designs available, finding the ideal fit for your needs is crucial for effortless ice production. We’ve rounded up 10 of the top old ice cube tray contenders to help you make an informed decision for your home bar or kitchen.
The best old ice cube tray prioritizes durability and ease of use, with many opting for stainless steel to avoid plastic odors, like the 11 18-cube model. Alternatively, silicone trays, such as the FDDBI Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey or KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray, offer flexibility for easily releasing large, slow-melting cubes ideal for cocktails.
Best Old Ice Cube Tray Picks, Compared
| Image | Product | Buy |
|---|---|---|
Best Pick 1  | OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray Best for: No-spill convenience | Check Price |
Best Pick 2  | Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Best for: Large whiskey spheres | Check Price |
Best Pick 3  | Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays, 2-Pack Combo, 2 Inches Best for: Two large cubes | Check Price |
Best Pick 4  | Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: 2″ Big Silicone Ice Best for: Two big cubes | Check Price |
Best Pick 5  | KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack), Easy Release 2″ Best for: Two easy cubes | Check Price |
How We Picked
To identify the best old ice cube tray, we meticulously evaluated each product based on crucial buyer concerns: build quality, real-world performance, safety, durability, and standout features. We prioritized trays offering robust construction like stainless steel and BPA-free silicone, ensuring longevity. Performance was judged on ease of ice release, cube uniformity, and whether they prevented odor absorption.
Unique features such as no-spill lids, efficient stacking capabilities, and attractive ice shapes were also considered. Trays that compromised on material quality or ease of use were ruled out, leading us to the top performers that deliver exceptional value and ice-making satisfaction.
What Most Buyers Get Wrong
Durability Beyond Plastic Cracks
When looking for an ‘old school’ ice cube tray, consider materials that stand the test of time, far surpassing brittle plastics. Stainless steel trays, like the one from 11 18 cubes, offer a robust, plastic-free, and non-toxic alternative. This avoids the common pitfall of trays cracking over time and ensures your ice remains odor-free, unlike some older plastic models that can absorb freezer smells.
The Easing Out of Frozen Squares
The hallmark of a great old ice cube tray is a design that makes releasing cubes simple, even when they’re frozen solid. Look for features that facilitate easy ejection, such as flexible silicone materials found in trays from KitchFort or FDDBI, which allow you to push cubes from the bottom. Even traditional designs, like the OXO Good Grips tray, incorporate innovative shapes and materials to prevent cubes from sticking stubbornly.
1. OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray
Best for: No-spill convenience for freezer stacking.
A sealed lid on this OXO tray prevents spills and allows for secure stacking, maximizing freezer space and preventing odor absorption. A comfortable handle ensures an easy grip for filling and transport, delivering clean tasting ice every time.
This BPA-free tray produces rounded ice cubes, approximately 1.25 inches in diameter, for easy release. The removable silicone lid is top-rack dishwasher safe, streamlining your cleaning process after use.
Pros
- Sealed lid for spill-proof transport and stacking
- Comfortable handle for secure grip
- Rounded cube shape for easy release
- Silicone lid prevents odor absorption
Cons
- Rounded cubes offer less surface area for rapid chilling
Perfect for busy individuals prioritizing a tidy freezer and hassle-free ice cube retrieval. Use it to stock up on standard-sized ice for everyday beverages.
2. Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube
Best for: Effortless large cube release for cocktails.
These FDDBI large ice cube trays feature independent cavities, allowing for easy pushing from the bottom to eject each big ice cube. The non-sticky flexible surface ensures a quick and smooth release, essential for crafting your favorite drinks.
Each of the two trays produces 4 large ice cubes, approximately 2 inches in size, ideal for slow melting. The included tight-fitting removable silicone lid keeps ice fresh and prevents spills.
Pros
- Independent cavities for easy cube ejection
- Generous 2-inch cube size for slow melting
- Tight-fitting lid prevents spills and odor
- Flexible silicone for effortless ice removal
Cons
- Two trays yield a total of 8 large cubes per batch
Designed for cocktail enthusiasts seeking to minimize drink dilution. Enjoy perfectly formed large ice cubes for your whiskey, cocktails, or iced coffee.
3. Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays, 2-Pack Combo, 2 Inches
Best for: Value pack of large spheres and cubes.
This Samuelworld combo pack offers significant value, providing 4 perfectly-shaped 2.5-inch ice spheres and 6 flawlessly symmetrical giant ice cubes. Constructed from high-quality, BPA-free materials, these trays ensure durability.
The 2.5-inch ice ball trays boast an integrated funnel system for efficient filling, simplifying the process. This set effectively creates large format ice to chill beverages thoroughly with less dilution.
Pros
- Includes both ice spheres and large cubes
- 2.5-inch size for slow melting
- Integrated funnel system for easy filling
- BPA-free, durable silicone construction
Cons
- Ice spheres can be more challenging to remove for some users
Ideal for the discerning home bartender who appreciates both aesthetics and functionality. Create impressive ice for spirits and sophisticated cocktails.
4. Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: 2″ Big Silicone Ice
Best for: Odor-free, large 2″ cubes with lid.
These large ice cube trays from GGUW feature an independent cavity design for convenient large cube release, with a non-stick silicone surface that ensures cubes slide out smoothly. The tight-fitting silicone lid helps prevent absorption of refrigerator odors.
This set includes three trays, each capable of making 4 large 2-inch ice cubes. The soft silicone material makes it easy to push cubes out from the bottom, and the lid prevents spills.
Pros
- Leak-proof lid prevents spills and odor absorption
- Non-stick surface for easy release
- Generous 2-inch cube size
- Three trays provide ample ice production
Cons
- Less efficient for making many small ice cubes quickly
A great choice for those who prefer large, slow-melting ice cubes for drinks like whiskey or bourbon. Keep your freezer tidy and your ice fresh with these spillage-free trays.
5. KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack), Easy Release 2″
Best for: Versatile 2″ cubes for drinks and portions.
KitchFort’s large silicone ice cube trays provide an easy-release solution for making 2-inch ice cubes, perfect for cocktails, coffee, or even freezing baby food. Crafted from food-grade, BPA-free silicone, these durable trays are a versatile kitchen essential.
Each of the two included trays allows for effortless release of 2-inch ice cubes by simply twisting and pushing from the bottom. These dishwasher-safe molds also accommodate freezing baby food, purees, and homemade portions.
Pros
- Makes two-inch, slow-melting ice cubes
- Durable, BPA-free silicone construction
- Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning
- Suitable for freezing food portions
Cons
- Twisting may require some effort for those with limited hand strength
An excellent option for individuals looking for multi-purpose frozen storage solutions. Use them for crafting large ice cubes or portioning baby food and sauces.
6. OXO Good Grips Silicone Small Ice Cube Tray with Lid
Best for: Uniform small cubes with stable base.
This OXO Good Grips silicone ice cube tray features a stable base that supports the tray during filling, transport, and storage. The flexible silicone makes it easy to remove uniform ice cubes.
The included lid helps keep ice from absorbing freezer odors and allows for stacking multiple trays, maximizing freezer organization. This single tray produces numerous small, uniform ice cubes.
Pros
- Stable base for easy filling and transport
- Uniformly sized small cubes
- Lid prevents odor absorption and allows stacking
- Flexible silicone for easy ice removal
Cons
- Produces smaller cubes, leading to faster dilution
A practical choice for everyday use, offering convenient handling and odor protection for your ice. Ideal for those who prefer smaller cubes for consistent chilling in various beverages.
7. W&P Crystal Ice Tray, Perfect Etched Large Cubes, Slow Melting
Best for: Artistically etched large cubes for elegance.
The W&P Crystal Ice Tray crafts four large, 2-inch cubes with an intricate, etched geometric design, resembling brilliant, cut crystals that instantly elevate your drink. This tray ensures your beverage chills to perfection with minimal dilution.
Each of the four cavities is designed for easy filling; simply fill from the top hole until water exits the side hole to create perfectly etched cubes. The large 2-inch size contributes to slow melting.
Pros
- Unique etched design for aesthetic appeal
- Large 2-inch cubes for slow melting
- Minimal dilution of beverages
- Easy fill system with overflow indicator
Cons
- Ice removal may require a brief warm water rinse
Perfect for hosts and mixologists aiming to impress with visually stunning, slow-melting ice. Serve elegant drinks with these crystal-like cubes for special occasions or everyday enjoyment.
8. OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray
Best for: Stackable, odor-free cubes with easy release.
This OXO Good Grips ice cube tray features an innovative rounded cube shape for easy release, and a sturdy lid that slides to dispense as many cubes as you choose. The cover prevents ice cubes from absorbing freezer odors, enabling efficient stacking.
The unit produces consistently shaped ice cubes, approximately 1.25 inches in diameter. Its BPA-free construction ensures safety, and the tray is dishwasher safe for hassle-free cleaning.
Pros
- Sturdy lid for controlled dispensing
- Rounded cubes release easily
- Cover prevents freezer odor absorption
- Stackable design for freezer organization
Cons
- Rounded cubes may melt faster than square ones
A user-friendly option for everyday ice needs, offering convenient dispensing and odor protection. Suitable for anyone looking for reliable ice production with easy handling.
9. Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray with lever (11″, 18 cubes),
Best for: Plastic-free stainless steel with lever.
This Captain Cranberry stainless steel ice cube tray offers a plastic-free alternative, creating 18 solid cubes with each use. Its retro lever handle cracks ice cubes free with a smooth pull, avoiding twisting or banging.
Made from premium food-grade 304 stainless steel, this 11-inch tray produces compact cubes that freeze quickly and melt slowly, minimizing dilution. It includes a divider for portioning.
Pros
- Plastic-free, non-toxic stainless steel construction
- Lever handle for effortless ice release
- Produces 18 solid cubes per tray
- Fast freezing and slow melting cubes
Cons
- Requires a flat surface for lever operation
An eco-conscious choice for those seeking a durable, chemical-free ice cube solution. Ideal for making ice for cocktails, iced lattes, or baby food without plastic concerns.
10. ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2), Sphere Ice Ball
Best for: Dual trays: 6 large spheres and 6 cubes.
The ROTTAY set includes two trays, one for shaping 6 crystal-clear 2-inch ice balls and another for 6 large 2-inch square ice cubes. Unique bumping seals ensure perfectly round spheres and balance design at the bottom prevents leaning.
The sphere trays feature a quick-open buckle for effortless release, and a bonus funnel is included for easy filling of the 2-inch diameter balls. The square tray also makes 2-inch cubes, offering substantial ice for drinks.
Pros
- Makes both large spheres and cubes
- 2-inch size for slow melting
- Quick-open buckle for easy sphere release
- Bonus funnel for convenient filling
Cons
- Sphere trays may take longer to fill initially
This versatile set is perfect for home bartenders looking to experiment with different ice shapes. Enjoy slow-melting spheres and cubes for a refined beverage experience.
Plastic Purity vs. Freezer Functionality
When selecting a best old ice cube tray, the singular objective must be acquiring the most efficient ice ejection for your specific usage pattern. This isn’t about aesthetics or novelty features, but pragmatic operation in a frozen environment.
The clear dividing line is between traditional plastic or stainless steel designs and their silicone counterparts, a choice that dramatically impacts how easily ice can be coaxed free. While the Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray with lever offers a robust, plastic-free alternative with its 18 cubes, the inherent resistance of frozen water to the metal demands a lever mechanism for effective release, a feature absent in simpler stainless designs. Conversely, silicone trays, exemplified by the KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack) and the FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube, leverage material flexibility.
The independent cavity design on these trays is key; pressing from the bottom is surprisingly effective for dislodging cubes, a stark contrast to the rigid forms that require more force or even running water.
The OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray and the OXO Good Grips Silicone Small Ice Cube Tray with Lid introduce a lid-centric approach to problem-solving. The no-spill lid on the former allows for stacking and angled storage, implying a focus on freezer organization as much as release. The latter, with its base supporting the tray, also prioritizes stability during the filling and transport stages, a consideration often overlooked by buyers focused solely on the final ice ejection.
The Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays, 2-Pack Combo, and the W&P Crystal Ice Tray introduce considerations beyond mere ejection. Samuelworld’s offering emphasizes value with a combo pack for both spheres and cubes, while the W&P Crystal Ice Tray positions itself on aesthetic differentiation with its etched design, appealing to those prioritizing beverage presentation over sheer ice volume or ease of release.
Ultimately, the ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2) with quick-open buckles for their 2” ice balls demonstrate that even within the silicone category, innovation in release mechanisms is possible, aiming for that effortless ejection some drinkers demand. For the user prioritizing speed and simplicity above all else, the FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube remains a strong contender due to its direct, no-fuss approach to getting large cubes out of the tray.
What to Look for in the Best Old Ice Cube Tray
Material durability
When choosing an old-fashioned ice cube tray, prioritize material that balances flexibility with durability. Silicone trays offer excellent flexibility for easy ice removal and are generally long-lasting, but some may retain odors. Opt for silicone that feels substantial and doesn’t easily tear.
For unparalleled robustness, stainless steel trays are a top choice; they won’t crack or warp over time and provide a clean, tasteless ice. While BPA-free plastic trays are common and affordable, scrutinize their construction for brittleness; thin plastic can become fragile and prone to breaking, especially with frequent use.
For consistent, reliable ice without fuss, select a solid stainless steel tray.
Ease of use and release
Focus on an ice cube tray that simplifies the process of getting ice out. Trays designed for single cube extraction allow you to pop out just what you need, preventing waste and ice clumping. Look for trays with clear indicators that the ice is ready for release.
Traditional twist-and-release mechanisms on some models are effective, but ensure the material offers sufficient grip and doesn’t feel flimsy. Trays with integrated handles provide better control during removal, especially when the tray is full and the ice is frozen solid.
For the most straightforward experience, choose a tray that allows for individual cube removal without requiring excessive force or awkward maneuvering.
Tray design and capacity
Consider the practical aspects of your ice cube tray’s design in relation to your needs. Standard rectangular cubes are the most versatile for everyday drinks and fit well in most glasses. While novelty shapes can be fun, their suitability depends entirely on your preference for aesthetics.
The number of cubes per tray directly impacts how much ice you can make at once; larger families or frequent entertainers will benefit from trays with higher cube counts. For efficient freezer storage, look for trays that are designed to be stackable, allowing you to maximize your available space and keep your ice supply organized.
For optimal utility and space-saving, select a standard-shaped, high-capacity tray that stacks neatly.
Which Should You Choose?
- If you want to prevent spills and odors while stacking, choose a tray with a sealed lid and a sturdy base.
- If you’re making ice for cocktails and prefer large, slow-melting cubes, choose a flexible silicone tray with independent cavities for easy release.
- If you’re looking for a plastic-free option and want odorless ice, choose a tray made from food-grade stainless steel.
- If you prioritize easy release of individual cubes and a unique ice shape, choose a tray with rounded ice shapes or a lever-activated release mechanism.
Quick Best Old Ice Cube Tray Buying Checklist
- Material: Choose durable, food-safe materials like BPA-free plastic, silicone, or stainless steel.
- Capacity: Select a tray that yields the number of ice cubes you typically need.
- Ease of Release: Look for designs that make popping out individual cubes simple.
- Durability: Opt for trays that can withstand repeated freezing and thawing without cracking.
- Shape: Consider if you prefer standard cubes or unique shapes for drinks.
- Dishwasher Safe: Check if the tray is easy to clean by hand or in a dishwasher.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Makes An Old-Fashioned Ice Cube Tray Superior For Certain Drinks?
Old-fashioned ice cube trays often produce larger, denser cubes that melt slower. This slow melting helps maintain the intended strength and flavor profile of your beverages for longer periods.
Are Silicone Old Ice Cube Trays Better Than Plastic Ones?
Silicone old ice cube trays offer greater flexibility, making cube removal easier without breaking. They are also generally more durable and less prone to cracking compared to many traditional plastic trays.
How Do I Prevent Ice Cubes From Sticking In My Old Ice Cube Tray?
Allowing the tray to sit at room temperature for a minute or two before twisting can help release ice. Running a little warm water over the bottom of a plastic tray also aids in freeing stubborn cubes.
Can I Use These Old Ice Cube Trays For More Than Just Water?
Absolutely. Old ice cube trays are versatile for freezing small portions of herbs in oil, fruit purees for baby food, coffee for iced coffee, or even broth for cooking.
What Is The Advantage Of A Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray?
Stainless steel old ice cube trays are exceptionally durable and can last for years, resisting cracks and warping. They offer a robust and often sleek alternative to plastic or silicone, imparting no flavor to the ice.
Final Words
Investing in the best old ice cube tray ensures consistently shaped, slow-melting ice for your beverages. Their simple design and durability offer a reliable way to elevate everyday drinks. Discover the perfect ice cube tray to enhance your chilling experience today.